Put the Same Idea in a Different Setting

Forget about trying to come up with an original story. You won’t and you’ll simply waste your time. However, what you can do is come up with an original way to tell a story. If you can tell a story in a unique and intriguing way, that’s far more important than trying to come up with a story that nobody has ever heard before.

There are two movies that on the surface may appear totally unrelated: “Alien” and “Shadow in the Clouds.” Yet underneath, they’re both telling the exact same story.

In “Alien,” a monster has gotten aboard a spaceship and the crew has to fight it off while trying to survive. Yet the idea for “Alien” came from a World War 2 myth that pilots of all nationalities swore was true.

During long flights, World War 2 pilots swore they saw little monsters, dubbed gremlins, land on their planes and start ripping out electrical wiring, puncturing fuel tanks, or tearing out hydraulic hoses to wreck the plane. This didn’t occur just once but multiple times with all nationalities.

Rather than describe a story about a gremlin tormenting a bomber crew during World War 2, the story of “Alien” shifted to science fiction, but the basic idea is the same where a monster gets on board a ship and starts killing the crew members one by one.

“Shadow in the Clouds” is based on the exact same story but actually depicts a World War 2 bomber crew fighting off a gremlin in an airplane. Same story but different setting. Yet that different setting along with different motivations of the characters creates a completely different story even though the plot is identical and based on the same idea.

So don’t worry about coming up with an original plot. Come up with an original way to tell the same story. Plot is far less important than creating a unique setting with distinctive characters we can care about.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

Related Posts

Writing Subtext in Dialogue

Most writers write dialogue and then try to add subtext. If you find this difficult, a much simpler approach is to identify the subtext first....
Read More

The Real Purpose of a Scene

The biggest mistake novices make when writing scenes is thinking the sole purpose of a scene is to give information about the story to the...
Read More

Why Your Story Needs an Emotional Logline

Nobody ever watches their favorite movies for the plot. That’s because they already know what’s going to happen. Instead, people watch their favorite movies over...
Read More

Don’t Write and Format at the Same Time

When most novices start writing screenplays, the first thing they do is rush out and buy a specialized screenwriting word processor like Final Draft. While...
Read More
Scroll to Top